Showing posts with label mediation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mediation. Show all posts

Monday, January 28, 2013

How Do I Stop the Other Parent From Making Disparaging Remarks About Me in Front of the Children?


A child custody court order or mediation recommendation routinely includes language to the effect that neither party shall make disparaging remarks about the other parent in the presence of the children. 

A mother tells the child, “You are just like your father.”  Then, the mother proceeds to disparage or put down the father for a host of things.  The mother says that the father is cheating on her or is not paying proper support to take care of his family.  The child is told that the father is a loser and does not work.  Or the father tells the child that she is just like her mother.  Then the father tells the child that the mother is cheating on him.  Or he says to the child that the mother is trying to keep the child away from him and interfere with their relationship.  There is no limit to the unkind and hurtful things that a child might be told by a parent about the other parent.  

A big problem is that half of the child is one parent and half is the other parent.  If the child is told these things, the child will feel that something is wrong with him or her if he or she is just like the disparaged parent.  The children are negatively affected by this parental disparagement.  

The disparagement raises the issue of parental alienation, which is difficult.  I tell my clients that a parent needs to work on his or her own behavior, because it is what he or she could control.  

Lawyers and judges should consider whether psychological intervention will help.  Even if the offending parent refuses to attend therapy, there might be an order that a child have sessions with his or her own psychologist.  

Proof at the time of trial of alienation or the making of disparaging remarks is sometimes difficult because the only witness is often the minor child.  New legislation has now made it easier to have an older child testify in court before the Judge.  But, this is not possible with younger children who must be represented in court by minor’s counsel or a therapist or mediator.  And, there is a continuing debate over the ultimate side effects to the child who testifies in court against one or both of his or her parents.

Many times, parents make disparaging statements to the other parent in emails or on Facebook. I tell my clients to write every email or Facebook post with the expectation and understanding that the judge will eventually read it and judge it. Emails to the other parent should be helpful to your child. Don't comment in a nasty way about the other parent's lifestyle. Where the judge is presented with various written emails containing disparaging remarks about the other parent, the judge will often assume the parent cannot refrain from making disparaging remarks in the presence of the child.

Richard Ross
Certified Family Law Specialist

Richard Ross is a Certified Family Law Specialist in California who is a member of the Collaborative Family Law Professionals in both Ventura and Los Angeles Counties.

_____________________________________________________________
The contents of this blog are provided to clients, prospective clients, internet users and the general community for informational and entertainment purposes only, and does not constitute legal advice. Further, the use of this blog and the transmission or receipt of the information provided in this blog will not establish an attorney-client relationship between you and Richard Ross Associates unless and until an attorney at Richard Ross Associates agrees that the Firm will undertake an attorney-client relationship with you. Do not transmit any confidential or sensitive information to Richard Ross Associates until a formal attorney-client relationship has been established.

The information contained within this blog should not be considered as a solicitation or an offer for an attorney-client relationship. Materials contained in this blog are of a general nature and should not be substituted for legal advice. You should seek the advice of a licensed attorney before acting or relying upon any information contained within this blog. Richard Ross Associates is providing this blog, the information and listings contained herein only as a convenience to you.

Friday, March 11, 2011

Collaborative AKA No-Court Divorce - A Better Way?

Collaborative divorce is a family law procedure by which the two parties agree that they will not go to court, or threaten to do so.  The parties strive to reach a fair settlement through a series of four-way meetings between the two parties and their lawyers.   This is a relatively new approach to conflict resolution.  It is based on the realization that traditional litigation is not always helpful to families, and often is damaging.  Its popularity is increasing dramatically.

Collaborative law differs from mediation. In mediation the mediator is a neutral third party who doesn't represent either side, though each party usually has a lawyer available to consult with throughout the mediation process. 


The Collaborative process involves treating each other respectfully and satisfying the interests of all family members rather than trying to gain individual advantage.  The Collaborative process sets a positive tone so that the husband and wife can work to satisfy both of their interests.  The process can reduce unnecessary and destructive conflict and avoid litigation.

The key document in a collaborative case is the Participation Agreement. It is a contract signed by the participants, which sets forth the rules for the process.  The Participation Agreement includes a Court Disqualification Clause, which states that if the parties do not resolve the matter in the Collaborative process, neither attorney will represent the parties in any contested litigation between them. 


Thus, the Collaborative process can increase the motivation of all parties and attorneys to reach a settlement.  If negotiations break down and either husband or wife decides to proceed with a litigated court divorce, both parties need to hire new attorneys and the collaborative attorneys are out of a job.  As a result, everyone in the Collaborative process focuses exclusively on reaching agreement.  All parties and attorneys focus on negotiation from the very beginning of the process.  Collaborative attorneys work to negotiate constructively and avoid attacking the other side.  What is said in the settlement meetings remains confidential.

The Collaborative process typically involves a team of Collaborative professionals who have specialized training in collaborative divorce skills.  Using a team approach helps the couple make fully-informed, carefully considered settlement decisions, using professionals with different skills.  The team is assembled based on the individual needs of the case.  For example, separate divorce coaches, who are mental health professionals, can help one or both of the parties to deal with emotional, relationship, and parenting issues.  Child development specialists, financial and real estate professionals may be hired jointly to provide unbiased information and advice.  These specialists are neutral, which saves each party time and money hiring his or her own experts.

Collaborative professionals usually have had special training to help promote constructive settlements.  By investing the time and money for professional training, Collaborative professionals demonstrate a commitment to constructive negotiation. 


Richard Ross
Certified Family Law Specialist

Richard Ross is a certified family law specialist in California who is a member of the Collaborative Family Law Professionals in both Ventura and Los Angeles Counties.